Why Showing Your Mistakes and Bloopers Actually Sells

Walk into any corporate boardroom, and you’ll find a group of terrified people trying to look entirely flawless. They spend thousands of pounds on sleek brochures, perfectly lit photoshoots, and carefully scripted videos where nobody so much as blinks out of turn.

They do this because they believe "professionalism" is a shield that protects them from criticism.

But out in the real world, customers are getting incredibly bored of it.

We are bombarded with hundreds of polished, airbrushed adverts every single day. We’ve developed a sort of radar for fake perfection. When a company looks too flawless, too clean, and too sanitised, a little alarm bell goes off in our brains. We start wondering: What are they hiding? What is the catch?

If you are running a small, local business, trying to copy these massive corporate giants is a losing game. You don't have their budget, and frankly, you don’t need it. Your biggest advantage is that you are a real, living, breathing human being.

And the fastest way to prove you’re human is to stop hiding your mistakes.

The Pratfall Effect

There is a fascinating bit of human psychology discovered back in the 1960s called the Pratfall Effect.

The theory is simple: if someone is highly competent at what they do, but they make a small, clumsy mistake—like spilling a bit of coffee on their suit—people actually like them more. It makes them relatable. It takes them off a pedestal and brings them down to earth.

The same rule applies to your business.

When you only post perfect photos of your finished work, your audience might respect you, but they won't necessarily feel connected to you. But when you show the messy reality of how you got there—the paint spill, the burnt loaf of bread, or the massive tangle of wires you had to spend three hours sorting out—something magical happens.

Your audience stops looking at you as a faceless vendor and starts rooting for you as a person. They want you to succeed. And when people want you to succeed, they are infinitely more likely to buy from you.

Competence vs. Clumsiness

Before you go posting a video of yourself accidentally setting fire to a client's kitchen, we need to draw a very firm line in the sand.

There is a massive difference between being humanly clumsy and being bad at your job.

For the Pratfall Effect to work, your audience must believe you are brilliant at what you do first. If you only ever show disasters, you don’t look relatable—you just look like a liability.

• The bad mistake (Do not show this): Showing up three hours late to a job because you forgot to look at your diary, or doing a shoddy piece of work and shrugging it off. This just makes you look incompetent.
• The relatable blunder (Show this): A video of you dropping a tin of paint, swearing quietly under your breath, and then showing the satisfying, highly professional process of how you cleaned it up.
  Showing how you handle a mistake actually proves your professionalism far better than pretending mistakes never happen. It shows you have integrity, resilience, and a sense of humour.

The Industry Split

We also have to acknowledge that the rules of this game change depending on what you do for a living. Some businesses have a lot more room to play with than others.

If you run a high-charm, low-risk business—like a bakery, a craft shop, or a local cafe—you can lean into the chaos. A burnt batch of sourdough is endearing. A slightly wonky ceramic mug is "character." The stakes are low, so your audience will happily laugh along with you.

However, if you run a high-risk, trust-based business—like a local accounting firm, an independent financial adviser, or IT support—you must be incredibly careful.

If a financial planner posts a photo of a chaotic desk covered in coffee stains with the caption "Oops! Can't find my client's tax returns under here!", it doesn't make them look human. It looks like an upcoming audit.

If you are in a trust-based industry, keep your bloopers entirely away from your core service. Don't show mistakes about client data or money. Instead, keep the blunders light and personal: stumbling over your words on a video, getting locked out of your own office, or having your dog hijack a Zoom call. Show you are a human, but keep your professional competence absolute.

Bloopers are Seasoning, Not the Main Course

Even if you are in the most relaxed, creative industry on earth, you must keep an eye on the frequency of your blunders.

If every single post you publish is a story about a disaster, a ruined project, or a chaotic day, people will eventually start to wonder if you can actually do the job.

Think of your blunders like salt. A little bit of seasoning makes the meal delicious, but if you dump a whole cup of salt into the soup, it’s completely ruined.

The vast majority of your marketing should still show your finished, brilliant work. Show the gorgeous kitchen installation, the perfectly iced wedding cake, or the flawless bookkeeping spreadsheet. Once you have firmly established that you are excellent at your trade, then you can sprinkle in the occasional behind-the-scenes mishap to keep you human.

The Danger of the "Fake Flub"

We must also warn against the absolute worst marketing sin you can commit: the staged blooper.

Audiences today have an incredibly sharp radar for digital nonsense. If you try to manufacture a clumsy moment—like "accidentally" dropping a tool on cue or rehearsing a tongue-twister to look cute on camera—your audience will spot it instantly.

The moment people realise a mistake was staged for the sake of "engagement," all the trust you've built instantly vanishes. You go from being a relatable local business owner to a phoney.

True vulnerability cannot be scripted. If nothing went wrong this week, don't invent a disaster. Just show the normal work. Only share mistakes when they actually happen naturally.

Where to Put the Mess

Not all digital spaces are created equal. You shouldn't throw your business's dirty laundry all over your virtual front lawn. You need to keep a clear boundary between your shop window and your backroom chat.

• Your shop window (Keep it polished): Your website homepage, your Google Business profile, and your pinned social media posts are evergreen. These are the places people go when they are actively looking to hire you right now. Keep these spaces professional, clean, and focused on your very best, most successful work.
• The backroom chat (Show the mess): Temporary, casual spaces like Instagram Stories, quick behind-the-scenes reels, or your weekly email newsletter are perfect for the everyday chaos. These are the places where your warm audience hangs out—the people who already know you and want to see the real, day-to-day grit of how you run things.

Three Simple Ways to Share the Chaos

You don’t need to orchestrate anything. Just start capturing the normal, everyday realities of running your business. Here are three incredibly easy ways to do it in your casual channels:

1. The "Work in Progress" Mess

If you are a joiner, a builder, or a maker, your workshop is probably a disaster zone for 90% of the day. Don't clean it up just to take a photo. Post a picture of the sawdust-covered floor or the mountain of cardboard boxes you need to recycle. Write a simple caption: "The glamour of running a small business. If you need me today, I'm at the bottom of this pile."

2. The "Oops, We Messed Up" Post

If you run an online shop or send out a regular newsletter, you will eventually send the wrong link or make a glaring typo. Instead of panic-deleting the post, own it immediately with a bit of dry wit. Send a quick follow-up with the subject line: "Well, that was embarrassing." Explain that your finger slipped, and perhaps offer a tiny discount code called MYBAD or OOPS.

3. The Outtake Reel

If you record videos of yourself talking to the camera, do not delete the moments where you stumble over your words, forget what you were saying, or get interrupted by your dog barking. At the end of your helpful video, tack on three seconds of you rolling your eyes at yourself after a tongue-twister. It breaks the tension and makes the viewer smile.

Stop Hiding the Scaffolding

Think about your favourite local businesses. You probably don’t love them because they have the most sterile, perfectly branded Instagram feed in the country. You love them because of the way the owner greets you, the passion they have for their craft, and the little quirks of their shop.

Your flaws are not a weakness; they are your signature.

Stop trying to hide the scaffolding of your business. Let people see the mess, the drafts, the mistakes, and the clean-ups in your daily stories. When you show people that you are real, you stop having to sell to them. They will simply want to do business with you because they like who you are.

Let’s make this easy for your business

Ready to maximize your digital presence? See how our team handles everything from clean code to search engine visibility through our ongoing management services

Ongoing Website Management

If you have a question about your website, SEO, or a new project, you can get in touch with us. We are always happy to help.

Get In Touch